Forum

TOPIC: Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #140812

  • masman
  • masman's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Level 5
  • Posts: 244
  • Karma: 0
Dumbledore will keep on teaching Harry through his painting in the headmaster's office, but what I really want to know is if Harry is going to stay at Hogwarts even though he says he isn't and who the new headmaster is going to be.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #140885

The Matrix wrote:
Is Hermione legal yet?
After December in the 7th book she is.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #140906

  • Captain N
  • Captain N's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Stage A - 1
  • Posts: 3089
  • Karma: 916
keith, evil dude wrote:
Sorry, but Rowling has stated several times that he's dead.Besides, all conclusive evidence points to he is obviously dead.
Where? Post links to interviews if you don't mind.All the evidence actually points that DD is alive and well actually.Unspoken spells are a high point in HBP, just because Snape says the words "Avada Kedavra" dosen't mean he performed said spell.The killing curse hit Dumbledore and he went flying out of the window, hung in mid-air for a second or two, then fell to the ground. When has the AK curse ever done that? Diggory just slumped over, dying instantly. Frank Bryce fell over, dead before he even hit the ground. Why now is it such a different effect? The spell is said to simple make the person cease to live. There's never a mention of the spell being able to blow someone back.When has Dumbledore EVER gave the appearence he was afraid of death? Or that death was a bad thing? He's made it a point that the fear of death is Voldemort's greatest weakness. So when he begged Severus, what makes you think he would pleading for his life? He's been betrayed before. Had Snape really killed him, had Dumbledore been cornered like that, why would he choose then to break down when so many times before he'd been betrayed ( Quirrel, Voldemort, Karkaroff, Malfoy, Fudge etc ) he kept such a calm composure, now he's freaking out? No.Why freeze Harry? Dumbledore used the impediment curse on Harry before the person coming into the room was identified. You could say it was a death eater, but how would Dumbledore know? If he had no idea of the events going on, it could've just as easily been a member of the Order. No, Dumbledore knew this battle was going to happen, knew Malfoy would come, was fully aware that Malfoy had to kill him and that Snape had made the unbreakable vow.What was the purpose of Rowling showing so early on in HBP that Snape was really a bad guy? All the secret bad guy revelations had been saved to the end of the book in all five of the previous books ( Quirrell, Riddle, Pettigrew etc ) why now would she spoil the biggest bad guy turn in the first few chapters of the book? It dosen't add up.Snape had revultion and hatred etched on his face. Why? When had they EVER shown Snape to have even the slightest dislike of Dumbledore? Nothing in the past or present had eluded to Snape hating Dumbledore. Anger, dislike, "just doing my job" those are one thing. To be revulsed by something is an entirely different deal.Speaking of that, there was another instance where someone did something to Dumbledore that revulsed the guilty party. Harry feeding Dumbledore the water from the bowl in the cave. I mean the wording was almost exactly the same when Harry fed DD the water as when Snape set to kill him. Why? Harry didn't want to do it. Neither did Snape.No body. There's not a single word spoken of Dumbledore's body after he's found after the fall. Nothing. They even say that the body he saw at the funeral was what he "assumed" to be Dumbledores body. Where did the fire come from that encased the body in the casket? Why was there an after image of a phoenix?Speaking of Phoenix's, where was Fawkes when Dumbledore was cornered? Come on man, he wasn't out eating. The bird was told to stay away.Snape and DD were fighting about something that Hagrid overheard. What was it? Snape said he didn't want to do it anymore, which would imply what? He didn't want the DADA job anymore? Not likely. The more obvious answer, he didn't want to spy on Voldemort anymore. My guess is that it was because he knew what it would finally entail, which led to Dumbledore's saying firmly "You said you would do it." Spy on him? When has DD ever been forceful in making people do something that would place them in mortal danger? Only when it was absolutely nessecary. What information would Snape have to gain by spying on Voldemort? Not much. They've made it a point that Voldemort dosen't open up to ANYONE. Dumbledore knew that. Hell, he said it. No, DD was demanding Snape follow through with this attempt to kill him.Dumbledore knew Voldemort cursed the DADA job. He knew Snape had old ties to the Death Eaters. Why give him the DADA job? Something he knew Snape would never last more then a year doing? He had to ensure Snape would do as he was told. This was a slightly less precise, but nevertheless effective means of assuring the end result would play as DD sought out.Snape's a good guy. Dumbledore's not dead.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #140922

  • masman
  • masman's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Level 5
  • Posts: 244
  • Karma: 0
Snape's a good guy but Dumbledore is dead.http://www.hp-lexicon.org/Read up because you don't know your stuff.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #140992

  • Captain N
  • Captain N's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Stage A - 1
  • Posts: 3089
  • Karma: 916
Oh yeah, that thought provoking one sentence and your link to some generic search site with big penis among other Harry Potter search items, really shut me down :eyes:
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #141079

  • Chim
  • Chim's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Level 6
  • Posts: 298
  • Karma: 498
after reading that part about how voldemort's snake (or living things in general) could be one of the horcruxes, i remember thinking about the possibility that Harry could be one of those unaccounted for Horcruxes. etc, etc, then he'd have to kill himself or find some clever way around it to destroy it and kill Voldemort.then i realized how awfully cliche that would be, and rather uninteresting.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #141081

  • masman
  • masman's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Level 5
  • Posts: 244
  • Karma: 0
Captain N wrote:
Oh yeah, that thought provoking one sentence and your link to some generic search site with big penis among other Harry Potter search items, really shut me down :eyes:
For your information The Harry Potter Lexicon is the number one source for HP info you ass. :smt072
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #141084

  • Blank
  • Blank's Avatar
Dumbledore is alive, Snape is good. Malfoy's father will take over as the headmaster and Voldermort will rock the school like it's ever been rocked. They'll find out that Voldermort was actually a pretty rad guy and Dumbledore allows him to be the headmaster.End.
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #141085

  • Captain N
  • Captain N's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Stage A - 1
  • Posts: 3089
  • Karma: 916
masman wrote:
For your information The Harry Potter Lexicon is the number one source for HP info you ass. :smt072
Check your link stupid.Also, Blank I knew you didn't read HP. Thanks for getting my hopes up :(
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Harry Potter Book 7 Discussion 14 years 1 month ago #141116

  • alexsan
  • alexsan's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Stage A - 1
  • Posts: 6339
  • Karma: 535
it will cost 50-60 dollars and be 800 pages long and to make more money they will cut it up into 2 parts so it will be 100-120 dollars for the end of the saga. Just a guess
XBL: Neezie1990PSN: sillycoreSteam: Neezie3DS: 3737-9522-5541
The administrator has disabled public write access.